Is bankruptcy the answer?
When You Can't Pay Enough to Shrink Your Student Loans and Other Debt
by Gary Foreman
Getting a Reluctant Spouse to Consider Credit Counseling
Is Debt Consolidation a Good Idea?
Can Bankruptcy Wipe Out Student Debt?
Dear Dollar Stretcher,
My husband and I have been with a credit counseling service for two years. We started off with $22,000 in debt and are now down to $15,000. We're making monthly payments that were less than without the service. Now our student loans are coming due (two masters degrees and two kids later), which are about $100,000. We are considering bankruptcy to stop paying on the old debt and get prepared for the student loan payments. We have been trying for two years and feel as if we have gone nowhere and want to declare bankruptcy to get back on our feet.
Kay in Southern California
Talk about some big numbers! It's easy to see why Kay and her husband feel overwhelmed by the debts facing them.
Many recent graduates have large student loans when they graduate, and that's understandable. A good education can be a worthwhile goal, and education can pay off handsomely for some. According to Monster.com, the median earnings of a person with a master's degree can range from $52,300 to $121,000, which is typically $17,000 more than someone with only a bachelor's and $33,725 more than someone with only a high school diploma.
But these earnings figures include people who have been in the workforce for years. And Kay implies that earnings alone won't solve their problem. Let's take a look and see if we can't help them decide whether bankruptcy is the best course of action.
We'll begin by looking at some facts that will affect the decision. First, student loans are not eliminated in bankruptcy unless the court determines that they would represent a serious hardship. So even after a successful bankruptcy, Kay and her husband will still need to repay them. That means that the most debt that they can eliminate would be the $15,000 they're currently handling through the credit counselor.
Next, Kay needs to realize that a judge can throw out her Chapter 7 bankruptcy petition. If the judge feels that Kay could repay a reasonable portion of the loan in three to five years, or finds that her income is greater than her expenses, the application will be denied.
Even if Kay is granted bankruptcy, there will still be consequences. She can expect to give up a second car, bank and investment accounts and family heirlooms. The bankruptcy filing will remain on her credit report for ten years. That will make it difficult to obtain new credit.
It doesn't look like filing for bankruptcy will really help. The majority of the debt would remain and so would some nasty consequences.
Am I a good candidate for bankruptcy?
So what can Kay do about the mountain of student debt? The first thing is to realize that they're not alone. According to Bloomberg.com, roughly 11.3% of student loans are in default; many grads struggle with repayment.
The second thing is to realize that failure to repay student loans on schedule can have consequences. Credit bureaus can be notified of your delinquency. IRS refunds can be claimed to help repay the loans. The creditor can even collect 15% of your disposable pay for debt repayment.
Kay might want to consider 'consolidating' her student loan. It's similar to refinancing your house. One program could be tailor-made for her situation: the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program. The program considers need in setting up a repayment plan for the borrower.
A number of repayment options are available. A standard plan carries a fixed rate with a 10-year repayment period. An extended plan allows you to schedule the repayment period to up to 30 years. There's also a graduated plan, in which payments increase as your earning ability increases. Finally, there's also a plan (not available to everyone) that will adjust your payments to your income.
Kay can find out more about consolidation programs offered through the government on the U.S. Department of Education's Federal Student Aid website.
We can all learn from Kay's predicament. It's always tempting to borrow money. We feel like we need the money for something important like a college education. And borrowing is easy to do. Fill out an application, sign on the dotted line and they give you a check. Or whip out the plastic and sign the slip. Nice and easy.
But any time you borrow money there's a cost to you. That cost won't come until later. But when it does come, it might overshadow the benefit you received earlier.
In Kay's situation, she and her husband gave up certain options when they accumulated that much student debt. They might not have known it at the time, but they were effectively saying that when they graduated they wouldn't drive new cars. They would live in a lesser home and probably rent for a longer period of time than most graduates. Fancy vacations wouldn't be part of their lifestyle. Starting a family would need to be delayed if they were to avoid severe financial hardship.
Is that a stiff price to pay? For some it's too high. They'd rather reduce their class schedule, work more and get their degree a little later without having a debt to repay.
Find out if you can benefit from student loan debt help.
For others, the higher income that goes with a degree makes the post-graduate sacrifice worthwhile. But, regardless of the answer, everyone should know the costs before making a decision that will affect their lives for many years.
Kay and her husband can expect a struggle. If they declare bankruptcy it will be reflected on their records for 10 years. In either case it will probably take that long for them to repay the student loans. Hopefully, the additional earning power that they have will make the repayment a little easier.
Updated January 2017
Gary Foreman is a former financial planner and purchasing manager who founded The Dollar Stretcher.com website and newsletters in 1996. He's been featured in MSN Money, Yahoo Finance, Fox Business, The Nightly Business Report, US News Money and CreditCards.com. Gary shares his philosophy of money here. You can follow Gary on Twitter or visit Gary Foreman on Google+. Gary is also available for audio, video or print interviews. For more info see his media page.
Take the Next Step:
- Find out if you can benefit from student loan debt help.
- Am I a good candidate for bankruptcy?
- Stop struggling financially. Take these steps to get out of debt and begin the journey to financial freedom!
- Stop struggling to get ahead financially. Subscribe to our free weekly Surviving Tough Times newsletter aimed at helping you 'live better...for less'. Each issue features great ways to help you stretch your dollars and make the most of your resources. Subscribers get a copy of Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist And What You Can Do About It for FREE!
Share your thoughts about this article with the editor.
I often wonder if I should be seeking professional help to get my debt under control! Tell us: Yes, I'd like to find out if I am a good candidate for credit counseling or No, I don't think I need couseling but I would like to find out how I can pay off my credit cards more quickly.
More Debt Tips & Tools
- 6 smart strategies for paying off your credit cards
- 5 great second jobs to bring in extra cash
- Pay down debt now or save: Here's how to choose
- Can I get a debt consolidation loan with bad credit?
- Adjusting to sudden economic change
- Stop burying your head in the sand and face your financial fears
- Surviving a cash crisis
- Are you a shopaholic?
- This week's Readers' Tips
- Reduce your debt step by step
- Am I a good candidate for credit counseling?
- Do I have a debt problem?
- Compare personal loan rates
- Get free answers to financial questions
- Get free answers to legal questions
- Calculate the real cost of your debt
- Debt pay-down calculator
- Calculate the true cost of paying just the minimum